In this video you can see a 16 year old schoolboy pile drive a kid who has been bullying him for years. The video was posted on facebook by one of the bully’s friends, and from there ended up on Australia’s national news services. Don’t be fooled by the relative sizes of the kids, according to the accompanying story the larger boy in this footage had been bullied for years at his school, and he finally snapped when the little shit in the video started punching him. This video has created quite a controversy in Australia, because the school suspended the bullied child (as well, I think, as the bully) and lots of “experts” have been paraded in front of the media to talk about how this response is the wrong way to handle a bully. Here, for example, we have an opinion piece in the Herald telling us that this sort of thing is terribly wrong. Commenters on every piece, and on the youtube video, seem to be universally positive, however, and cite an age-old adage, that bullies are fundamentally cowards who cave in when someone strikes back.
I was bullied a lot at school, and for me the sight of the little shit in this video staggering to his feet and swaying about, barely conscious, was profoundly pleasant. I laughed aloud, and wished the bigger boy had followed it up with a nice solid punch to the face. Having been in the same situation as that bullied child, I know that on that day he made the amazing discovery that actually, most people are weak cowards, and even the biggest and scariest people back down if you confront them. His whole world will have changed, and the confidence he will have gained from watching that little snotling wobbling in front of him will never be forgotten. When I was a child I was knocked unconscious by bullies twice, and had a kneecap dislocated once. I was subjected to all the taunts and behaviour described in the linked article, and I discovered at the age of about 12 – when I first kicked one of my antagonizers as hard as I could in the balls, and left him mewling in a little ball in the middle of the playground – that the only language bullies understand is the language they speak. Drag them down from their arrogant heights in front of their mates, make them cry and scream and they will never again command any power over you. But even if your tactic backfires – as so many experts quoted over this incident will claim – and your bully returns fire, you have already won. I never won a fight at school – even the kid I testiculized came back (after an hour rummaging around in his pants desperately checking if his shrivelled little balls were still intact, no doubt) and punched me in the face, several times, while the whole school watched and cheered him. But no one in that school ever said a word against me ever again. The same is true of every other bully I ever confronted. Of course, if you can win, all the better, but I was the smallest kid in school with no sports skill and no muscles, so I always lost. But it was always a strategic defeat for the bully, because his bubble of superiority was punctured, and all the kids who laughed along with him knew they couldn’t entertain themselves at my expense.
By the final year of school, of course, all those kids knew that the years they’d wasted on being cool at school were coming back to bite them on the arse – me and my uncool nerdy mates had an out, we were heading to university and the big city, and my bullies were being left behind in a fading smelting town, with no work prospects and no qualifications. Even the pretty girls eventually abandoned them to hook up with a rich, nerdy banker. The only legacy the fucknuts at school can leave you from their bullying is the loss of your own confidence, and it’s so easy to stop them from doing even that. You just have to stand up to them, and even if it hurts, afterwards it’s you who has the pride, you who have shown you’re the stronger person, and everyone around them knows it even if they never tell you. Plus, you’ll be taking an important lesson into your adult life: if you stand up to people, they give you what you want. This is a lesson the bullies never learn, and if you’re the person who stands up to them you get the chance to teach them just how worthless they really are. Hopefully that lesson will persist through their whole future, cursing their social interactions, their sex lives and their careers, as some small recompense for all the children whose confidence they broke with their pointless cruelty.
So I take my hat off to that kid, I toast his success, and all the experts can take their meaningless advice and shove it up their arses. In honour of that video and his efforts, I’d like to share with you all a story from my high school days, which I think is the best “revenge against a bully” story that happened in my school days. It doesn’t concern me, but the nastiest and most violent bully in the school, and a mild-mannered kid from my friendship group who had been taunted by him for years. Let’s refer to them repsectively as Mr. Fucknuckle[1], and Plucky Ginger.
My school in this dusty smelting town had a tradition amongst kids that when a pressing matter needed to be resolved, the disputants in question would go to the nearby churchyard and duel it out. The rest of the troglodytes at my school would toddle along and form a cheering circle, and thus would important debates about academic achievement be resolved in the time-honoured fashion. Now it so happened that Mr. Fucknuckle had a long-standing enmity with another kid, perhaps not so much bullying as a general character dispute[2]. So they agreed to meet at the churchyard and because both were pretty nasty, it attracted a larger than average crowd. Now, to his credit, Mr. Fucknuckle was a pretty savage fighter, and big, and scary, and he won the fight pretty quickly (I think it was to “first blood” in this instance).
However, amongst the crowd was Plucky Ginger, who had been enduring low-level taunts and the occasional violent instance from Mr. Fucknuckle for years. I don’t know what happened this particular day – maybe it was the stress of coming exams, maybe he’d seen a video on the internet[3] – but something inside him broke, some barrier against all the rage of the underdog, and out of the crowd he charged, while Mr. Fucknuckle was still basking in the glory of the moment. Before anyone could stop him he launched a surprise attack, bowled Mr. Fucknuckle over, and sprung atop him. From this position he launched a classic “ground ‘n pound” attack, punching him over and over in the face in a frenzied and insane manner. He did a lot of very nasty-looking superficial damage to Mr. Fucknuckle’s screwed-up, ugly little mug, and true to their characters, the troglodytes in the crowd cheered him on. Finally one of Mr. Fucknuckle’s sycophants ran over and dragged him off, but this wasn’t the reason Plucky Ginger stopped. It turns out he had punched so frenziedly and repeatedly that at some point in the attack he had broken his hand.
So, Plucky Ginger retreated from the field of battle and Mr. Fucknuckle slunk away, dripping blood and covered in bruises, his invincibility finally and convincingly disproved by the boy everyone knew he had been bullying for years. His aura was shattered, and Plucky Ginger made anew. The fact that he had broken his hand venting his rage earned him even greater respect, and from that time on he was never again subjected to a single bad word by any of the varied crew of trogs and sub-humans in our Shared Learning Space.
So if you’re reading this, kids, take my advice and the advice of generations of bullied kids everywhere: ignore the experts and do what the kid in the video did. Smash the bully, as hard as you can, without fear of the consequences. Even if he hits you back, he has already lost, and when you see the banking of the evil light in his eyes, the power that flows through you will keep your spirits aloft for years to come.
—
fn1: I never suffered under the tyranny of Mr. Fucknuckle because he tried me on early in my time at the school – year 11 – with a simple and age old antagonism. During touch football practice I touched him, and in front of the whole PE class he said to me (in his typically slovenly bully’s “language”) “Touch me again and I’ll bash ya, mate.” So in front of everyone, right there and then, I touched him. Challenged in such an upfront way, there was nothing he could do – bashing me would look trite and silly (and the PE teacher was there) and he’d gain nothing, since I clearly wasn’t scared of him. He uttered the typical “huh, you aren’t worth it” but never again ventured to do anything except exchange the odd uncivil grunt with me. If only he had been so sensible with Plucky Ginger…
fn2: Hard though it is to imagine that teenage boys, let alone Mr. Fucknuckle, have a character on which to base a dispute
fn3: Which actually hadn’t been invented yet[4], and of this fact I am eternally grateful. Bullying is much much nastier now that the immoral little fucksticks can bully you out of school hours without even being in your presence[5]
fn4: I know I know, strictly speaking it had been, just not disseminated…
fn5: Although let’s get this clear, verbal abuse is not worse than physical abuse. When people physically abuse you, they tend to also verbally abuse you. It’s not like they hit you silently.
March 21, 2011 at 1:18 pm
I broadly agree with your comments, but I’d add two addendums.
1. When fighting back against a bully the aim (in my opinion) isn’t to puncuture their “aura of invincibility”, it’s to raise the cost of bullying you so high that not even the dumbest future long-term unemployment receiptent will want to pay that price. As such how much damage you take is a personal assessment – what’s important is setting high cost to bully you.
2. You mention that verbal bullying isn’t worse, but I think this is a grey space. Clearly getting the shit kicked out of you everyday is worse than being teased every day, but in most cases of bullying I know of regular physical bully is the easiest one for others to spot and stop (i.e. it looks like child abuse if nothing else) and is the one most likely to trigger an outburst from the victim that puts the bully in their place. On the other hand verbal abuse can continue for a period of years, is harder to spot, difficult to stop and is unlikely to be reported. Additionally if the victim does eventually snap then they’re the one who is regarded as the bad guy while the bully gets off without official punishment, which means the “cost of bullying” (from point 1) is set much lower and their less likely to actually stop.
March 21, 2011 at 1:26 pm
True, true, but…
1. I’m not an economist, so I’m happy to conflate “raising the cost” and “lowering the rewards”. Ideally you do both. And the rewards (as well as the cost) of bullying are closely tied to the social benefits it grants in the twisted and unhappy world of teenagers
2. I agree with your assessment of verbal bullying but in my experience the verbal bullying you describe is part and parcel of the physical process. This kid’s experience matches that; he was teased and slapped and called “fat” and all the rest of it as well as being punched. But it’s true, if they’re only verbally bullying you it’s hard to stop them and/or raise the cost, so it can go on longer.
Verbal bullying (only) is rare amongst boys in my experience. I often talk about this with the redoubtable Miss Ember – giving advice to boys about what to do when they’re being bullied is easy, because at some point they’re gonna get pushed or punched, and they can go mediaeval on that idiot’s arse. Not so for girls.
But the internet certainly complicates things in this regard.
March 21, 2011 at 1:35 pm
The bullying I experience was purely verbal. I don’t recall any incidients of physical bullying at my school, despite it having a reputation as having a bullying problem. I believe that it’s bully was purely verbal and based largely around the sporty kid teasing the smart kids in class and around the school premises.
March 21, 2011 at 1:38 pm
Your school had one bully? I had to confront 6 personally in my first year in my smelting town. Three of those confrontations ended with fights, and two were clearly intended to become violent but I headed them off early. That was just me; there were others picking on other people.
Did you go to school in Shangri-La or something?
March 21, 2011 at 1:46 pm
Opps, I meant to say “I believe that it’s bullying was purely verbal”.
March 21, 2011 at 6:22 pm
http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2011/3/18/
March 21, 2011 at 10:25 pm
Great sentiment from Penny Arcade.
The bullies in my school were almost always the most popular kids in the class. They generally were pretty bright and/or good at sports. Most kids liked them, and the teachers liked them. There were a few edge cases. One was basically just physically two years more mature than the rest of us, several inches taller and stone heavier and while definitely a bully, it was generally in a “fun” way, and delivered with a smile on his face. He was probably the most physical (but not in a punch your light’s out sense, as he’d have put kids in hospital) but I probably minded him least of all (he was made head prefect!). One was a little more vicious and actually enjoyed the pain, someone to be avoided if he was walking down the corridor. One was outright evil and specialised more in the mobilisation of class sentiment against you (though he’d quite happily punch the crap out of you as well). This latter git was one of the most popular kids in school and was probably the one who caused me the most grief. I did turn on him one day (didn’t quite pile drive him I have to say), and I did get momentary support from the flock, but as in your experience he ultimately pounded me and I lost the fight. Not sure things were especially better afterwards to be honest but I did get a few pats on the back for trying.
Physical abuse usually revolves around a few individuals who can perhaps be avoided/detected/piledrived as you suggested. Continuous, pernicious verbal/social abuse can I think be more damaging in the long run because it’s far easier for a larger group of people to join in with and maintain the abuse/ostracization. If every hour of every day is filled with contempt your life gets pretty bleak. That such abuse can now continue even outside of school due to the ‘advances’ of social media is pretty terrifying to consider.
The Samaritans mailed me recently. It consisted of a glossy, stiff card, professional school photo… of a load of empty seats. This represented the number of children who’d taken their lives from bullying (I can’t remember over what time period). Quite an affecting photo! It was to raise money for staffing anti bullying phone lines, not something I was aware they did.
I assume you’ve read Ender’s Game? I only come across this book a few years ago and greatly enjoyed it but in particular I wondered how I might have reacted had I read it while I was in the thick of things. Would it have inspired me to have a go a bit earlier perhaps (hopefully without actually killing anybody though)? Do you agree with Ender’s attitude of absolute and total OTT response to a threat to remove the threat in future? Perhaps it should be the first thing anti bullying organisations hand out to victims?
March 23, 2011 at 11:07 pm
Bullying is never an acceptable act. I blame the schools and the parents who refuse to see what their children are really like. The bull about it will help toughen a child up to be bullied is one of the dumbest ideas around. I know that teachers have witnessed this type of thing and watched it happen never once stepping in unless the bullied child strikes back. Then the victim is demonized for protecting themselves. This world society has become too violent and worships bullies. If you study history this is a major sign of decay and is followed by the collapse of society.
I am a woman in my 50’s and menopausal. I had neighbors who were in their 20’s and 30’s who egged my car, yelled nasty things at me, and tried to intimate me. Apparently being an older woman made me a target. I finally had enough and let them know that I know how to kill and I could go military on their behinds and being menopausal I might not stop once I got started. They needed to know just because someone is older it doesn’t mean they don’t know a thing or two, they did not know what training I had. And it is a stupid thing to harass menopausal women if we snap we snap big time. Don’t mess with hormones going out of control. Instead of being drunk on their front yards now they go in when they see me. Enough is Enough!
I think the young boy being bullied showed a lot of restraint he could have done a lot more and I think the schools and policy makers should be held accountable for letting such things go on unchecked. The mother of that bully is the type that causes this in the first place. Your child is not a sweet young thing he is a terror and should be dealt with as such. I’ll bet she bullied girls when she was in school and thought it was fun.
When I was in school in the mid 60’s and early 70’s this sort of thing was still considered wrong and the bully was the one who was in trouble not the victim. Where are the teachers who would grab the bully by the ear and march them to the principals office? You can’t tell me the teachers there did not know what was going on. It says a lot about the people in charge of teaching our children now. Things sure have changed.
June 9, 2011 at 6:05 am
To anyone who is being bullied, child or adult, my advice, from years of torment, is to NEVER back down, or you will remain a target forever. Even if you have to just scream your lungs out for an hour, that usually stops things because people start becoming aware that there is a problem, and you won’t be wont the effort to the bully.
Or, if you know a good lawyer, sue ONE of the bullies parents. Violence is illegal.
September 7, 2013 at 4:01 pm
Hi
I’m a middle aged female whose been bullied by neighbouring shopkeeper for four years. He’s insane; has done this to others too.
I did all the right things, even got a restraining order as he’s assaulted me but it’s all been a waste of time – this dripster is relentless.
The last time he assaulted me I gave him a really hard kick in the leg which gave him a hell of a fright… he threatened to kill me soon after!
I’ve discovered that violence has been the best tactic so far…ridiculous for a middle aged woman to have to do this but I have exhausted all other options. He tries it again, it’s gonna be very ugly.
Fortunately I’m quite tall and strong and had practice fighting when I lived at home, and he is a weedy fruitball. Bring it on!
September 10, 2013 at 9:12 am
Thanks for commenting! It continually amazes me that bullying extends into adulthood. I can kind of understand it from children, but the idea that people would reach middle age and still think this is a good way to work out their own insecurities is frankly amazing. Good luck!
September 30, 2020 at 12:56 pm
Total necro comment here but I would tend to back Paul on the verbal vs physical. I think it’s changed a lot. I went to government primary schools (mostly pretty middle class admittedly except one year in a rural area) and an all male private high school in late 80s/90s Australia (a bit younger than you faustus?). Most of the bullying was already verbal and physical fights were rare. I got in about half a dozen fights between about 9 and 13 and I think that was more than average – I was bullied a bit and then had a chip on my shoulder for a couple years after. And the fights were very restrained, almost stylistic – mostly punching in the guts but not the face. I was very bad at graduated response which is probably one reason I stopped fighting. I would either take it too far or be surprised when the other kid did.
My impression (no kids so very impressionistic) is that physical violence is even more restrained these days (again, in middle class schools at least) but the internet makes the verbal stuff much more constant and nastier. But then if the bullied child lashes out physically they are seen as in the wrong more than if the bullying was also physical. So nastier all round but it does make your advice less applicable.
So yeah, I guess a lot of people are (relatively) going to school in Shangri-La. Doesn’t seem to help much. The words, and really I guess the hostility and exclusion from the group they express, are more dangerous than anything but hospital grade physical injuries. Of course simply allowing more physical violence wouldn’t necessarily help either.
October 2, 2020 at 9:41 am
Thanks for your comment Hobbes. Here at the Faustusnotes Academy we’re fully supportive of necromancy! I guess we went to different types of school, because I think I was in half a dozen fights just in my penultimate year. I went to an extremely violent high school though – I should probably someday write up the story of the Churchyard Meatgrinder, or the Shuttering of the Paedo Teacher, or a number of other quite horrible things that happened in that school (this was the town where my brother found a dead body in his friend’s car and was treated as a suspect by the police – high times!)
My problem with the physical/verbal distinction is that physical violence is almost always accompanied by all the hallmarks of verbal bullying too. It’s not like they don’t go together. In a school in the UK (much earlier than my violent Aussie school) I was subject to just verbal and emotional bullying (excluded from all social groups except when someone bothered to call me “gay”, the insult du jour of rural British schools in the 70s/80s), but in another school in the UK I got that treatment plus several of the school’s gym boys would also regularly hit me and attack me in the schoolyard. I had no friends in either school, but only in one school was I regularly physically attacked as well. (I dealt with that by kicking the lead bully very hard in the balls when he was trying to hurt me one day, leaving him retching on the ground, and was then immediately chased around the school by the entire student body, who all verbally abused me for an hour straight until the boy had recovered and was able to come and punch me repeatedly in the head. Then the teachers took me aside to punish me).
Also I’ve just recovered from knee surgery for an injury I sustained from a bully 35 years ago, which I think I can safely say was one of the more traumatic incidents of my childhood (and he wasn’t even punished). This injury has plagued my life, and I didn’t even know the connection until finally this year a decent doctor dealt with my regular kneecap dislocations properly.
One reason I think that people don’t understand this is that most people are only verbally bullied, and don’t understand that physical bullying is in addition to, not instead of, verbal bullying. But in the Australian context I think a lot of people don’t get it because physical violence was quite common in Oz when we were kids – the bullies would fight each other too, and so would the bullied, simply because Oz was a pretty violent place. I think this led people to misinterpret physical bullying as an outgrowth of violent cultural displays, but it’s not. It’s separate to those ritualistic macho displays, and is added on to verbal and emotional bullying. In some schools I went to there was also a division of labour, with girls doing the verbal and emotional bullying, and then boys laying violence on top of it.
I certainly hope things have improved. The attitude of schools to bullying when I was a child was terrible, and if I could go back in time now to see how these schools dealt with pre-teenage me I think I would be dispensing a lot of violence to the teachers. And I do think that emotional and verbal abuse and bullying is harder to stop than physical bullying, which is probably why there is less of the latter now but the former persists. Since my primary response to being bullied was to hit the person doing it, I really don’t think I’ve got any answers to that. I hope the modern teaching community are taking it much more seriously than they did in my day though!
October 5, 2020 at 12:34 pm
It does seem to be taken more seriously now (this had kind of started already when I was at school). As you say, the emotional and verbal stuff is harder to police than the physical, so more of it remains. Though there’s still a fair bit of physical including filming of fights/attacks (won’t hyperlink to trigger spam filter but easy enough to search).
Certainly agree physical + verbal > verbal, and they usually go together when left unchecked. I was just agreeing with Paul that it’s more verbal nowadays, and that makes physical retaliation a worse strategy for the bullied.
Incidentally, I work in government bureaucracy which is scarily like school in a lot of ways. But one thing I have to admit about modern HR and managerialism, even though it usually drives me insane – it does seem to cut down on the bullying, at least the really explict nasty stuff. So maybe there is some hope. Statistically seems like youth suicide has declined a but but depression is getting worse?