Is it just me, or has the Guardian embarked on a project of excessive tastelessness[1]? In the last two days they have shown video footage of 17 people dying in a hot air balloon (apparently you can see people jumping to their deaths) and of a man being dragged to his death by a South African police van. WTF? I don’t want to watch people die. I was always of the understanding that snuff videos were an urban myth. Call me crazy, but I don’t think media outlets should be showing footage of real people dying. I don’t want my death to be on film, and I don’t want to watch you die. Maybe occasionally there is some social value to watching you die, but in general I think your death should be something kept between you, your family and your god or gods.
I remember years ago some stupid American politician shot himself in the face in front of the media, and pretty much every Australian TV station chose not to play it. I recall one station even had a statement about why they “censored” the sight of a man blowing his brains out. What has happened in the intervening years that grainy footage of some holiday-makers having an otherwise great day ruined by their horrible fiery deaths has become news? Why do I need to see some kid in South Africa being murdered?
I think I can chalk this up as another example of how journalists and the media generally are losing track of reality. But let me say this: to the best extent that I can, I will try to avoid watching you die. Obviously, some stupid media may trick me into watching their horrid snuff films, but if I have any say over the matter, I will not watch you die.
I’m sure that will make you feel better when you do.
—
fn1: Obviously for a lot of people this has been a rhetorical question for a very, very long time now.
March 1, 2013 at 8:38 am
Fair enough. Each to his own, though. I personally have no problem with it, aside from the whole “children shouldn’t be watching it” debate.
The media standards falling? Yes, and nothing new there, as you know. But if I were to think about this from a more international perspective, many other nations/cultures have very different attitudes to what should and shouldn’t be shown on TV. I have a fifteen minute video somewhere on my hard drive of a documentary aired on a middle-Eastern TV station about head-hunter massacres of Javanese transmigrants in Kalimantan. Mind-blowing for a Western mind think it was aired, since most of the 15 minutes is live footage of massacre-by-machete. But I’m betting you won’t be putting your hand up to watch that one, right? 🙂
March 1, 2013 at 10:01 pm
I don’t have a problem with showing death where it’s of some kind of documentary value (though I won’t comment on your decapitation porn). However, in a news report I think it’s mostly just salacious, and to me that’s really sick.
March 3, 2013 at 12:26 pm
There’s at least one good reason to watch someone die. To gain the ability see Thestrals. http://harrypotter.wikia.com/wiki/Thestral
Other than that, it’s generally best avoided.